Ah —Christmas time is here! And so is the Grinch… no, really! I saw him myself this past week in Columbus, Ohio. Terri and I had a blast as we joined our daughter, son in law and little miss Kairi in attending the Broadway production of “How the Grinch stole Christmas!” It was a hoot and just watching my sweet granddaughter’s eyes captivated by the theatrics was an incredible “Papaw” moment! Every Christmas season it seems, I have a desire to absorb the Grinch story in one form or another, whether by way of cartoon… or another! “Sorry, bad Suess effort!”

There is a very small moment that seemed to jerk my mind into the present when little Cindy Lou Who after catching old Mr. Grinch in the act of stuffing her Christmas tree up the chimney asks the questions.. but why? This brought to mind and article I had read a few years back in Relevant magazine by Austin Sailsbury which observed “the Grinch has become the most well-known of Dr. Seuss’ stories.

As Dickens did with Ebenezer Scrooge, Dr. Seuss literally redefined the essence of what it means to be a heartless fun hater. Set in the cheery-cheeked hamlet of Whoville, How the Grinch Stole Christmas is a Seuss-ified critique of both the over-commercialization of Christmas (the Whos with all their presents) and its antithesis: holiday humbuggery (old Mr. Grinch).

But, in the end, the Grinch realizes Christmas is not about material things that can be “stolen,” but instead about the intangible joys of the season. Taking another cue from Dickens, the Grinch is ultimately redeemed, which is not only fitting but required for any great story about Christmas—after all, it’s the beginning of the story of redemption itself.”

So with the oft debated but much evident 2015 War on Christmas in full swing what could possibly be done to help those who oppose Christmas vigorously and even those who labor against the celebration of the Christ Child’s birth but don’t really know why. How can they begin to realize that, to borrow a line from the Grinch himself… What if Christmas, he thought, doesn’t come from a store. What if Christmas…perhaps…means a little bit more!”

So back to the question “But Why?” Well first off there are a lot of questions. Good ones in fact and no wonder since Christmas is so commercialized it’s easy to miss (The Reason for The Season.)

Several years ago there was a story told about this young couple who were planning to have their little baby christened in their beautiful home. It was a cold wintry day. And as the guests began to arrive, they were greeted by the husband and wife. As the couples entered they tossed their coats and scarves on the bed that was adjacent to the living area. Everyone arrived at approximately the same time.

After a brief time of fellowship, someone asked, where’s the baby? The mother quickly dashed into the bedroom and discovered that the coats and the scarves had been carelessly thrown on the bed where she had placed the little baby.

The little child was almost smothered at his own party! Seems like that’s the byproduct of the over commercialization of Christmas. But notice secondly, the But Why is asked because there are a lot of people who need to know what Christmas is.

Years ago Dave Barry observed, “To avoid offending anybody, the school dropped religion altogether and started singing about the weather.

At my son’s school, they now hold the winter program in February and sing increasingly non-memorable songs such as “Winter Wonderland,” “Frosty the Snowman” and—this is a real song—“Suzy Snowflake,” all of which is pretty funny because we live in Miami. A visitor from another planet would assume that the children belonged to the Church of Meteorology.” We as a culture have successfully removed the message of the birth of our Lord and Savior Jesus Christ in a manger in Bethlehem from the minds of many for a couple of generations now!

The question is but why, and the answer is important because the message of Christmas is still the greatest story ever told! The best of wordsmiths is Max Lucado who wrote… “If our greatest need had been information, God would have sent us an educator; If our greatest need had been technology, God would have sent us a scientist; If our greatest need had been money, God would have sent us an economist; If our greatest need had been pleasure, God would have sent us an entertainer; But our greatest need was forgiveness, so God sent us a Savior.” The greatest need for every life has been supplied in the person of that little baby in a manger in Bethlehem.

Oh it matters to me and it matters to you, it matters to everyone under the sky… It matters, It matters oh believe me it matters, and it answers the question to the question… But Why!


By Rev. Tim Throckmorton

Crossroads Church